Big Bang theory

Flawed?

evolution of the universe
The image above represents the evolution of the universe, starting with the Big Bang. The red arrow marks the flow of time. (Source: NASA)
logo
 
galaxy cluster
Galaxy Cluster Abell 370

big bang theory
Big Bang theory envisions an expanding universe.

The Big Bang theory, first proposed in 1927 by the Catholic priest Georges Henri Joseph Édouard Lemaître, posits that the universe has expanded from a dense primordial center and that this expansion began 13.3 to 13.9 billion years ago. It is the currently prevailing cosmological model for the origin of the universe. Now a team of astronomers including Ivelina Momcheva of the Carnegie Observatories report that a distant cluster of galaxies, that we see as it looked 11 billion years ago, looked quite ancient even at that early date — only 2 or 3 billion years after the date the Big Bang theory says the universe began.

The Carnegie team has discovered the most distant cluster of galaxies ever found. It looks remarkably similar to the much older present-day galaxy clusters.

"We were looking for clusters of galaxies when the universe was still very young," says Carnegie's Momcheva, who did the spectroscopic analysis which led to the discovery of the cluster. "One might think that the clusters we find would look young as well. However, in this cluster we found a number of surprisingly ancient-looking galaxies. This cluster resembles modern-day clusters, which are nearly 10 billion years older."

Casey Papovich
Casey Papovich

"It is like we dug an archeological site in Rome and found pieces of modern Rome in amongst the ruins," adds lead author Casey Papovich of Texas A&M University.

CLG J02182-05102, as the cluster is called, contains approximately 60 galaxies, including several enormous red galaxies at its center holding 10 times as many stars as the Milky Way. Such galaxies were thought to be rare in the universe at this early stage. Similar galaxy clusters today have had billions more years to develop and grow.

The cluster was first detected using NASA's Spitzer Space Telescope, which is sensitive to the infrared light emitted by the galaxies. The researchers observed the high density of galaxies within CLG J02182-05102, but could not determine from the Spitzer data whether its galaxies are indeed gravitationally bound, as is the case with true galaxy clusters. For these measurements, they used an advanced spectrograph on the Carnegie Institution's Magellan/Baade 6.5 meter telescope at the Las Campanas Observatory in Chile. Analyzing the faint light from seven galaxies near the center the cluster, they found that the galaxies had an average redshift of 1.62. "This means that we are seeing it the way it looked 9.6 billion years ago," says Momcheva. "Since then it has moved away from us as the universe has expanded. Today the distance to the cluster is 15 billion light years."

Galaxy clusters are the largest gravitationally bound structures in the universe, and studying the new discovery will help researchers understand how galaxies evolve and form clusters. CLG J02182-05102's large red galaxies are unexpected because most galaxies at that time were still rapidly forming stars, and, as a result, appear smaller and their emitted light bluer.

For the galaxies in ClG J02182-05102 to have become chock full of old, red stars so quickly compared to their contemporaries, these galaxies must have "lived fast and died young," Papovich said.

Or is there something wrong with the theory? Perhaps the universe didn't begin with a bang after all?

Astrobiology >>

The Andromeda GalaxyThe Andromeda Galaxy. (Source: NASA)


Most shared on Macroevolution.net:




Big Bang theory © Macroevolution.net